Branding

What makes a good logo? (It’s rarely the clever bit)

A black and white hand pinching finger and thumb almost together on mint, with the words Shrink it. Still you?

Ask most people what makes a good logo and they’ll talk about the idea. The hidden arrow, the clever double meaning, the shape that’s secretly two things at once.

Those are lovely when they happen. But they’re not what makes a logo work. Plenty of brilliant businesses have logos with no hidden meaning at all, and plenty of clever logos are let down by everything else.

A good logo does a few plain jobs, and does them everywhere.

It works small

Your logo will spend most of its life tiny: a profile picture, a browser tab, the corner of an email, an embroidered polo shirt. If the detail disappears or the words become a smudge at that size, it isn’t working. Simple shapes and confident lettering survive being shrunk. Fine lines and long taglines don’t.

It works in one colour

At some point your logo will be printed in black, cut out of vinyl, etched or stamped. If it only makes sense with a gradient or five colours, it’ll fall apart. A good logo still reads in a single colour, and colour then makes it better, rather than holding it up.

It looks like your price level

People judge what you charge before they read a word. A logo that looks home-made tells them to expect home-made prices, however good the work is. One that looks considered and confident lets you charge for what you’re worth. We’ve written more about this in why branding sets your price level.

It stands apart in your sector

Every sector has its clichés: the roof outline for roofers, the leaf for anything green, the swoosh for anything fast. They feel safe, but they make you look like everyone else on the list. A good logo still feels right for the sector, without blending into it.

It will last

Trends date quickly. A logo built on this year’s fashionable font will look like this year in five years’ time. The ones that last are built on simple shapes and well-chosen lettering, and they can be refreshed later rather than replaced.

Where the idea comes in

The idea does matter, but it should come from the business, not from a trick. For The Event Catering Co., the mark is an oyster fork, with three prongs that form the “e” of event, and a nod to the Mersea oysters and local produce at the heart of every menu. It works because it’s true to them, and it still works small and in one colour.

Sometimes the best idea is already there. With arlo consultancy services, we didn’t start again. We kept what was working and made it stronger and cleaner.

A logo is the start, not the whole brand

A logo on its own can’t carry a business. It needs colours, fonts and a way of using them that hold together across your website, vans, socials and paperwork. That’s the difference between a logo and a brand identity, which we cover in logo or brand identity: which do you need?.

How we design logos

We start by getting to know the business: who you’re for, who you’re up against and how you want to come across. We then present 3 to 4 concepts, and refine the one you choose over up to 4 rounds of changes. You deal directly with the designers throughout. A logo project takes from two weeks, and every brand identity comes with guidelines, so it’s used properly from day one.

If you’re looking for logo design in Colchester or anywhere in Essex, we’d love to hear about your business.

Free mini brand audit

Still not sure? Get a straight answer.

Tell us about your business in five minutes. We’ll send back your brand score, how you compare with a competitor and the three changes that would make the biggest difference.

Get my free mini audit

Or take the 10-point brand check, or tell us about your business.

Brands people choose. Websites that win work.

Got an idea you want to talk about?